PGRR #31 · Revision Request

PGRR031 Implement 95% Facility Rating Limit in the Planning Criteria

Rejected sponsor PLWG posted 2013-06-12 ercot.com

ReasonThe Operations and Planning Synchronization Task Force (OPSTF) identified several factors that could lead to overloads in operations that were not observed in planning studies.

Created2013-08-28

Rejected2014-08-12

Sections Affected

4.1.1.2

Summary

This Planning Guide Revision Request (PGRR) changes the planning criteria such that system improvements are planned when studies show Facilities will be loaded up to 95% of their applicable rating.

Timeline

Jun 12 '13
ROSFiled by PLWG
Jun 26 '13
PLWG Planning Working Group (PLWG) Meeting
- 031PGRR-01 Implement 95% Facility Rating Limit in the Planning C Jun 18 '13 · Revision Request
- 031PGRR-02 CPS Energy Comments 061913 Jun 19 '13 · Revision Request Comments
Aug 28 '13
PLWG Planning Working Group (PLWG) Meeting
PLWGDeferred/Tabled Tabled
“Consensus to table PGRR031”

→ PLWG Language Consideration
- 031PGRR-03 AEP Comments 062713 Jun 27 '13 · Revision Request Comments
- 031PGRR-04 LCRA Comments 071713 Jul 17 '13 · Revision Request Comments
- 031PGRR-05 Oncor Comments 082013 Aug 20 '13 · Revision Request Comments
Sep 12 '13
ROS Reliability and Operations Subcommittee (ROS) Meeting
- 031PGRR-06 PLWG Report 082813 Sep 3 '13 · Committee Report
Sep 25 '13
PLWG Planning Working Group (PLWG) Meeting
PLWGRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval Amended by the Jun 27 '13 AEP comments Amended by the PLWG comments
“Consensus to recommend approval of PGRR031 as amended by the 6/27/13 AEP comments and as revised by PLWG.”

→ PLWG for Impact Analysis review.
Oct 23 '13
PLWG Planning Working Group (PLWG) Meeting
PLWGRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval Forwarded → ROS
“Consensus to endorse and forward the 9/25/13 PLWG Report as revised by PLWG and the Impact Analysis for PGRR031 to ROS.”

→ ROS for consideration.
- 031PGRR-07 PLWG Report 092513 Sep 30 '13 · Committee Report
- 031PGRR-08 Impact Analysis 101013 Oct 10 '13 · Staff Report
- 031PGRR-09 LCRA TSC Comments 102213 Oct 22 '13 · Revision Request Comments
- 031PGRR-10 Edison Mission Marketing & Trading 102213 Oct 22 '13 · Revision Request Comments
Nov 14 '13
ROS Reliability and Operations Subcommittee (ROS) Meeting
ROSRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval
“To recommend approval of PGRR031 as recommended by PLWG in the 10/23/13 PLWG Report.” — Passed

→ TAC for consideration.
- 031PGRR-11 PLWG Report 102313 Oct 28 '13 · Committee Report
Nov 22 '13
PLWG Planning Working Group (PLWG) Meeting
- 031PGRR-13 ROS Ballot 111413 Nov 18 '13 · Revision Request Ballot
- 031PGRR-12 ROS Report 111413 Nov 19 '13 · Committee Report
Dec 3 '13
TAC Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) Meeting
TACRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval
“To to recommend approval of PGRR031 as recommended by ROS in the 11/14/13 ROS Report.” — Passed

→ ERCOT Board for consideration.
Jan 22 '14
PLWG PLWG Meeting
- 031PGRR-14 TAC Report 120313 Dec 5 '13 · Committee Report
- 031PGRR-15 TAC Ballot 120313 Dec 5 '13 · Revision Request Ballot
Jan 28 '14
TAC TAC Meeting
Motion Fails 12–16 roll call

“Goff/Pieniazek motion for TAC to file comments to ERCOT Board recommending tabling of PGRR031 while TAC conducts a study of issues raised in 01/28/14 presentation.”
Feb 11 '14
BOARD Board of Directors Meeting
BOARDDeferred/Tabled Tabled
“To table PGRR031.” — Passed

→ ERCOT Board for consideration.
- 031PGRR-16 Calpine Comments 020314 Feb 3 '14 · Revision Request Comments
- 031PGRR-17 EMMT Comments 020314 Feb 3 '14 · Revision Request Comments
- 031PGRR-18 AEPSC Comments 020414 Feb 4 '14 · Revision Request Comments
- 031PGRR-19 LCRA TSC Comments 020714 Feb 7 '14 · Revision Request Comments
Feb 27 '14
TAC TAC Meeting
- 031PGRR-20 Board Report 021114 Feb 14 '14 · Committee Report
Mar 26 '14
Listed without action at 3 meetings (Mar 26 '14 – Apr 23 '14)
- PLWG Meeting Mar 26 '14
- Board of Directors Meeting Apr 8 '14
- PLWG Meeting Apr 23 '14
May 29 '14
TAC TAC Meeting
- 031PGRR-21 ERCOT Comments 052114 May 21 '14 · Revision Request Comments
Jun 18 '14
Listed without action at 1 meeting
- PLWG Meeting Jun 18 '14
Aug 12 '14
BOARD Board of Directors Meeting
BOARDRejected Rejected
“To reject PGRR031.” — Passed
—
Posted since the last meeting
- 031PGRR-22 Board Report 081214 Aug 14 '14 · Committee Report