PGRR #22 · Revision Request
PGRR022 Removal of Planning Reserve Margin Calculation Methodology
ReasonThe calculation methodology used by ERCOT to determine the PRM for the semi-annual Report on Capacity, Demand and Reserves in the ERCOT Region (CDR) has historically been developed by the Generation Adequacy Task Force (GATF), subsequently approved by WMS, and then ultimately approved by TAC. In 2010, Market Participants decided that adding the PRM methodology into the Planning Guide would increase the transparency of the PRM methodology, and also provide a formal change and approval procedure via the PGRR process. Including the PRM methodology in the Planning Guide also provided for ERCOT Board approval. The PGRR approval requires a recommendation from the Planning Working Group (PLWG), ROS and TAC, and finally ERCOT Board approval. While this approval path achieved its objective (i.e., to improve and formalize the PRM approval process), it did not include language acknowledging that the PRM methodology had historically been under GATF and WMS purview. Discussions at WMS and ROS resulted in both subcommittees agreeing the PRM calculation methodology: (1) Is important enough that it needs to be transparent; (2) Needs input from WMS, ROS, and any other interested stakeholder body or Market Participant; and (3) Should receive ERCOT Board approval. It was also determined the best way to meet these three goals is to move the PRM methodology from the Planning Guide to the Protocols.
Created2012-10-25
Approved2013-03-19
Sections Affected
1.2.12.12.288.18.28.38.3.18.3.2
Summary
This Planning Guide Revision Request (PGRR) deletes Section 8, Planning Reserve Margin, from the Planning Guide. The Planning Reserve Margin (PRM) is being added to the Protocols via Nodal Protocol Revision Request (NPRR) 489, Planning Reserve Margin.
Timeline
- Oct 5 '12
-
Oct 19 '12
Listed without action at 1 meeting
-
Oct 25 '12
PLWG Planning Working Group (PLWG) MeetingPLWGRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval“Consensus to recommend approval of PGRR022 as submitted”→ PLWG IA Review
- Nov 7 '12
-
Dec 4 '12
PLWGEmail Vote / Unlisted MeetingPLWGRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval Forwarded → ROS“To endorse and forward the 10/25/12 PLWG Report and Impact Analysis for PGRR022 to ROS”→ ROS Consideration
-
Jan 10 '13
ROS Reliability and Operations Subcommittee (ROS) MeetingROSRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval“To recommend approval of PGRR022 as recommended by PLWG in the 12/4/12 PLWG Report” — Passed→ TAC Consideration
-
Feb 7 '13
TAC Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) MeetingTACRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval“To recommend approval of PGRR022 as recommended by ROS in the 1/10/13 ROS Report” — Passed→ ERCOT Board Consideration
-
Mar 19 '13
BOARD Board of Directors MeetingBOARDApproved Recommended for approval“To approve PGRR022 as recommended by TAC in the 2/7/13 TAC Report” — Passed
- Mar 27 '13