NPRR #667 · Revision Request

NPRR667 Ancillary Service Redesign

Rejected sponsor ERCOT posted 2014-11-18 ercot.com

ReasonMeets Strategic goals; market efficiencies/enhancements (see the NPRR submission form under "Key Documents" for the full list of reasons for this revision)

Created2014-12-11

Rejected2016-05-26

Sections Affected

This NPRR includes dozens of changes within Sections 23468and 9 of the Protocols. Please see the NPRR submission form under "Key Documents" for a complete list of impacted Sections.

Summary

This Nodal Protocol Revision Request (NPRR) improves Regulation-Up Service (Reg-Up) and Regulation-Down Service (Reg-Down); and replaces Non-Spinning Reserve (Non-Spin) and Responsive Reserve Service (RRS) Ancillary Services with a combination of four new Ancillary Services: Fast Frequency Response Service (FFRS), Primary Frequency Response Service (PFRS), Contingency Reserve Service (CRS), and Supplemenetal Reserve Service (SRS).

Timeline

Nov 18 '14
PRSFiled by ERCOT
- 667NPRR-01 Ancillary Service Redesign 111814 Nov 18 '14 · Revision Request
- 667NPRR-02 Impact Analysis 111814 Nov 18 '14 · Staff Report
Dec 11 '14
PRS PRS Meeting
PRSDeferred/Tabled Tabled
“To table NPRR667” — Passed

→ PRS for consideration
Jan 15 '15
PRS PRS Meeting
- 667NPRR-03 PRS Report 121114 Dec 12 '14 · Committee Report
Jan 30 '15
NPRR667 Workshop
- 667NPRR-04 ERCOT Steel Mills Comments 012115 Jan 21 '15 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-05 Invenergy Comments 012115 Jan 21 '15 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-06 TIEC Comments 012215 Jan 22 '15 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-07 Luminant Comments 012215 Jan 22 '15 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-08 DR Provider Comments 012315 Jan 23 '15 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-09 Apex Comments 012315 Jan 23 '15 · Revision Request Comments
Feb 12 '15
PRS PRS Meeting
- 667NPRR-10 CPS Energy Comments 020315 Feb 3 '15 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-11 CEI Comments 021015 Feb 10 '15 · Revision Request Comments
Mar 11 '15
Listed without action at 11 meetings (Mar 11 '15 – Dec 10 '15)
- NPRR667 Workshop 2 Mar 11 '15
- PRS Meeting Mar 12 '15
- PRS Meeting Apr 16 '15
- PRS Meeting May 14 '15
- PRS Meeting Jun 11 '15
- PRS Meeting Jul 16 '15
- PRS Meeting Aug 13 '15
- PRS Meeting Sep 10 '15
- PRS Meeting Oct 15 '15
- PRS Meeting Nov 12 '15
- PRS Meeting Dec 10 '15
Jan 14 '16
PRS PRS Meeting
- 667NPRR-12b Cost Benefit Analysis Hourly Output 2024 CAS 122115 Dec 21 '15 · Committee Report
- 667NPRR-12c Cost Benefit Analysis Hourly Output 2024 FAS 122115 Dec 21 '15 · Staff Report
- 667NPRR-13 ERCOT Comments 122215 Dec 22 '15 · Revision Request Comments
Feb 1 '16
FAST NPRR667 Workshop 3
- 667NPRR-14 SENA Comments 012516 Jan 25 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-15 Reliant Comments 012516 Jan 25 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-16 GDF SUEZ Comments 012516 Jan 25 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-17 FLNG Comments 012516 Jan 25 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-18 Sierra Club Comments 012516 Jan 25 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-19 CPS Energy Comments 012516 Jan 25 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-20 ESA Comments 012516 Jan 25 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-21 Calpine Comments 012516 Jan 25 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-22 TIEC Comments 012516 Jan 25 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-23 Co-ops Comments 012516 Jan 25 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-24 Apex Comments 012516 Jan 25 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-25 Direct Energy Comments 012516 Jan 25 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-26 RES Comments 012616 Jan 26 '16 · Revision Request Comments
Feb 11 '16
Listed without action at 1 meeting
- PRS Meeting Feb 11 '16
Mar 10 '16
PRS PRS Meeting
- 667NPRR-27 ERCOT Comments 030316 Mar 3 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-28 ERCOT Comments - Combined Responses 030416 Mar 4 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-29 ERCOT Comments - Calpine Response 030416 Mar 4 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-30 Wind Coalition Comments 030716 Mar 7 '16 · Revision Request Comments
Apr 14 '16
PRS PRS Meeting
PRSDeferred/Tabled Tabled
“To table NPRR667 for one month” — Passed

→ PRS for consideration
- 667NPRR-31 ERCOT Comments 040516 Apr 5 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-32 ERCOT Comments 041216 Apr 13 '16 · Revision Request Comments
Apr 28 '16
TAC TAC Meeting
- 667NPRR-33 PRS Report 041416 Apr 18 '16 · Committee Report
- 667NPRR-34 PRS Voting Ballot 041416 Apr 18 '16 · Revision Request Ballot
May 12 '16
PRS PRS Meeting
PRSRejected Rejected
“To reject NPRR667” — Passed
May 26 '16
TAC TAC Meeting
TACRejected Appeal Rejected
“To reject the 5/18/16 ERCOT appeal” — Passed
- 667NPRR-35 PRS Report 051216 May 16 '16 · Committee Report
- 667NPRR-36 PRS Voting Ballot 051216 May 16 '16 · Revision Request Ballot
- 667NPRR-37 ERCOT Appeal 051816 May 18 '16 · Legal filings and governance
- 667NPRR-38 PRS Advocate Position Statement 052416 May 24 '16 · Revision Request Comments
- 667NPRR-39 LCRA Position Statement 052416 May 24 '16 · Revision Request Comments
—
Posted since the last meeting
- 667NPRR-40 TAC Report 052616 May 31 '16 · Committee Report
- 667NPRR-41 TAC Voting Ballot 052616 May 31 '16 · Revision Request Ballot