NPRR #649 · Revision Request
NPRR649 Addressing Issues Surrounding High Dispatch Limit (HDL) Overrides
ReasonSubmitted pursuant to settlement agreement.
Created2014-10-09
Approved2016-04-19
Rejected2015-11-19
Sections Affected
1.3.1.14.6.56.5.7.1.106.5.7.1.136.6.3.9 (new)6.6.3.10 (new)6.6.5.19.5.3
Summary
This Nodal Protocol Revision Request (NPRR) proposes a compensation mechanism for Generation Resources that are issued a High Dispatch Limit (HDL) manual override that results in a real power reduction (subject to certain criteria). The proposed mechanism compensates the Qualified Scheduling Entity (QSE) for financial loss associated with variable cost components of Day-Ahead Market (DAM) obligations or bilateral contracts arising from the HDL manual override. ERCOT submits this NPRR to satisfy its obligations under a settlement agreement reached with Odessa Ector Power Partners, LP in Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUCT) Docket 41790. ERCOT’s submission of this NPRR does not imply ERCOT’s support for or opposition to the principles stated in this NPRR.
Timeline
- Sep 12 '14
-
Sep 23 '14
Listed without action at 1 meeting
-
Oct 9 '14
PRS PRS MeetingPRSDeferred/Tabled Tabled Referred → WMS“To table NPRR649 and to refer the issue to WMS” — Passed→ PRS for consideration
- Oct 29 '14
-
Nov 6 '14
Listed without action at 3 meetings (Nov 6 '14 – Dec 3 '14)
- Dec 10 '14
-
Dec 11 '14
Listed without action at 6 meetings (Dec 11 '14 – Feb 12 '15)
-
Mar 12 '15
PRS PRS MeetingPRSDeferred/Tabled Tabled Referred → WMS“To table NPRR649 and to refer the issue to WMS” — Passed→ PRS for consideration
- Apr 6 '15
- Apr 10 '15
-
Apr 16 '15
Listed without action at 1 meeting
- May 14 '15
-
Jun 3 '15
Listed without action at 1 meeting
-
Jun 11 '15
PRS PRS MeetingPRSRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval Amended by the Jun 4 '15 WMS comments“To recommend approval of NPRR649 as amended by the 6/4/15 WMS comments” — Passed→ PRS for Impact Analysis review
- Jun 17 '15
- Jul 16 '15
-
Aug 13 '15
PRS PRS MeetingPRSDeferred/Tabled Tabled Referred → WMS“To table NPRR649 and refer the issue to WMS; and requested that ERCOT consider alternative solutions/language to address the intent of NPRR649 at a lower cost” — Passed→ PRS for consideration
- Sep 2 '15
-
Sep 10 '15
Listed without action at 1 meeting
- Oct 7 '15
-
Oct 15 '15
PRS PRS MeetingPRSRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval Amended by the Sep 30 '15 ERCOT comments Remanded → PRS“To endorse the 8/13/15 PRS Report as amended by the 9/30/15 ERCOT comments; and requested a revised Impact Analysis be brought back to PRS for consideration” — Passed→ PRS for Impact Analysis review
-
Nov 12 '15
PRS PRS MeetingPRSRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval Forwarded → TAC Amended by the Nov 11 '15 Odessa-Ector comments priority 2016 · rank 1520“To endorse and forward to TAC the 10/15/15 PRS Report as amended by the 11/11/15 Odessa-Ector comments and the revised Impact Analysis for NPRR649 with a recommended priority of 2016 and rank of 1520” — Passed→ TAC for consideration
-
Nov 19 '15
TAC TAC MeetingTACRejected Recommended for approval Amended by the Nov 12 '15 TAC comments“To recommend approval of NPRR649 as recommended by PRS in the 11/12/15 PRS Report and as revised by TAC” — Failed
-
Feb 9 '16
BOARD Board of Directors MeetingBOARDRemanded Appeal Remanded → TAC“To grant the appeal of Koch Ag and remand NPRR649 to TAC, with the following instructions to report back on this matter at the ERCOT Board’s April 2016 meeting: 1. A recommendation of NPRR649 as proposed by Koch Ag in this appeal; or 2. A recommendation of a version of NPRR649 with alternatives for generator financial losses; or 3. If TAC votes not to recommend any version of NPRR649 for ERCOT Board approval, a review (including reasons for disapproval) of the alternatives considered by TAC that did not result in a version of NPRR649 recommended for approval. The ERCOT Board further instructs ERCOT to file comments on NPRR649 to assist TAC in the development of alternatives called for by the ERCOT Board’s remand of the NPRR.” — Passed→ TAC for consideration
- 649NPRR-23 TAC Report 111915
- 649NPRR-24 TAC Voting Ballot 111915
- 649NPRR-25(a) Koch Ag & Energy Solutions Appeal 120715
- 649NPRR-26(a) Koch Ag & Energy Solutions Position Statement 020216
- 649NPRR-26(b) Koch Ag & Energy Solutions Board Presentation 020216
- 649NPRR-27 TAC Advocate Presentation of TAC Action 020216
- 649NPRR-28 STEC & Golden Spread Position Statement 020216
- Feb 25 '16
- Mar 11 '16
-
Mar 31 '16
TAC TAC MeetingTACRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval Amended by the Feb 22 '16 ERCOT comments“To recommend approval of NPRR649 as recommended by PRS in the 11/12/15 PRS Report and as amended by the 2/22/16 ERCOT comments” — Passed→ Board for consideration
-
Apr 19 '16
BOARD Board of Directors MeetingBOARDApproved Recommended for approval Amended by the Apr 7 '16 ERCOT comments“To approve NPRR649 as recommended by TAC in the 3/31/16 TAC Report and as amended by the 4/7/16 ERCOT comments” — Passed
-
—
Posted since the last meeting