NPRR #1172 · Revision Request

NPRR1172 Fuel Adder Definition, Mitigated Offer Caps, and RUC Clawback

Approved sponsor Consumers posted 2023-04-11 ercot.com

ReasonMarket Efficiencies or enhancements

Created2023-05-10

Approved2024-02-01

Sections Affected

2.13.14.1.23.14.1.204.4.9.4.15.6.1.15.6.1.25.7.26.6.6.26.6.6.96.6.12.19.14.79.14.9and 25.5.2

Summary

This Nodal Protocol Revision Request (NPRR) creates a definition for Fuel Adder to provide clarity for which costs are included as routine and predictable versus which costs are exceptional. This NPRR also removes the Mitigated Offer Cap (MOC) multipliers, and creates a 100% clawback for Reliability Unit Commitment (RUC).

Timeline

Apr 11 '23
PRSFiled by Consumers
- 1172NPRR-01 Fuel Adder Definition Mitigated Offer Caps and RUC Clawback Apr 11 '23 · Revision Request
May 3 '23
WMS WMS Meeting - Webex Only
- 1172NPRR-02 IMM Comments 041223 Apr 12 '23 · Revision Request Comments
May 10 '23
PRS PRS Meeting
PRSDeferred/Tabled Tabled Referred → WMS
“to table NPRR1172 and refer the issue to WMS” — Passed

→ Language Consideration

Motion Carries 6–0 (6 abstain) roll call
May 24 '23
RCWG RCWG Meeting
- 1172NPRR-03 PRS Ballot 051023 May 12 '23 · Revision Request Ballot
- 1172NPRR-04 PRS Report 051023 May 12 '23 · Committee Report
Jun 7 '23
WMS WMS Meeting
Motion Carries 7.5–0 roll call

“To request PRS continue to table NPRR1172 for further review by the RCWG”
Jun 14 '23
PRS PRS Meeting
- 1172NPRR-05 WMS Ballot 060723 Jun 8 '23 · Revision Request Ballot
- 1172NPRR-06 WMS Comments 060823 Jun 8 '23 · Revision Request Comments
Jun 28 '23
Listed without action at 5 meetings (Jun 28 '23 – Aug 10 '23)
- RCWG Meeting - Webex Only Jun 28 '23
- WMS Meeting Jul 12 '23
- PRS Meeting Jul 13 '23
- WMS Meeting - Webex Only Aug 2 '23
- PRS Meeting Aug 10 '23
Sep 6 '23
WMS WMS Meeting
Motion Carries 5.66667–1.83333 (5 abstain) roll call

“To endorse NPRR1172 as amended by the 9/5/23 Consumers comments”
- 1172NPRR-07 Consumers Comments 090523 Sep 5 '23 · Revision Request Comments
Sep 13 '23
PRS PRS Meeting
PRSRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval Amended by the Sep 11 '23 CPS Energy comments
“to recommend approval of NPRR1172 as amended by the 9/11/23 CPS Energy comments” — Passed

→ Impact Analysis Consideration

Motion Carries 3.66667–2.33333 (9 abstain) roll call
- 1172NPRR-08 WMS Ballot 090623 Sep 7 '23 · Revision Request Ballot
- 1172NPRR-09 WMS Comments 090723 Sep 7 '23 · Revision Request Comments
- 1172NPRR-10 CPS Energy Comments 091123 Sep 11 '23 · Revision Request Comments
Oct 11 '23
WMS WMS Meeting
- 1172NPRR-11 PRS Ballot 091323 Sep 18 '23 · Revision Request Ballot
- 1172NPRR-12 PRS Report 091323 Sep 18 '23 · Committee Report
- 1172NPRR-13 ERCOT Comments 100423 Oct 4 '23 · Revision Request Comments
- 1172NPRR-14 Impact Analysis 101123 Oct 11 '23 · Staff Report
Oct 12 '23
PRS PRS Meeting
PRSRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval Forwarded → TAC Amended by the Oct 4 '23 ERCOT comments priority 2024 · rank 4070
“to endorse and forward to TAC the 9/13/23 PRS Report as amended by the 10/4/23 ERCOT comments as revised by PRS and the 10/11/23 Impact Analysis for NPRR1172 with a recommended priority of 2024 and rank of 4070 for Phase 2” — Passed

→ Revision Request Consideration

Motion Carries 5.83333–1.16667 (2 abstain) roll call
Oct 24 '23
TAC TAC Meeting
TACRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval
“to recommend approval of NPRR1172 as recommended by PRS in the 10/12/23 PRS Report; and the 10/17/23 Revised Impact Analysis” — Passed

→ Revision Request Consideration

Motion Passes 23–5 (2 abstain) roll call
- 1172NPRR-15 PRS Ballot 101223 Oct 16 '23 · Revision Request Ballot
- 1172NPRR-16 PRS Report 101223 Oct 16 '23 · Committee Report
- 1172NPRR-17 Revised Impact Analysis 101723 Oct 17 '23 · Staff Report
- 1172NPRR-18 Joint Commenters Comments 102323 Oct 24 '23 · Revision Request Comments
Dec 18 '23
RELIABILITYMARKETS Reliability and Markets Committee
- 1172NPRR-19 TAC Ballot 102423 Oct 27 '23 · Revision Request Ballot
- 1172NPRR-20 TAC Report 102423 Oct 27 '23 · Committee Report
Dec 19 '23
BOARD Board of Directors Meeting
BOARDRecommended for Approval Recommended for approval
“to recommend approval of NPRR1172 as recommended by TAC in the 10/24/23 TAC Report” — Passed

→ Revision Request Consideration
Feb 1 '24
PUCT
PUCTApproved Approved
“to approve NPRR1172 and accompanying ERCOT Market Impact Statement as presented in Project No. 54445, Review of Protocols Adopted by the Independent Organization” — Passed
- 1172NPRR-21 Board Report 121923 Dec 21 '23 · Committee Report
—
Posted since the last meeting
- 1172NPRR-22 PUCT Report 020124 Feb 5 '24 · Committee Report